CHOOSE MANAGED AGENTS IF
你希望 Anthropic 运营 Agent runtime
- 产品内嵌 agent 能力，API 触发正好适配系统
- 你接受 Anthropic 云执行、仅 Claude 模型与其定价
- 你更看重托管沙箱、Session、凭证、编排和恢复，而不是自己运营它们
竞品对比 · 事实核实于 2026-09-07
Orbi vs Claude Managed Agents
把 cattle 寄养在云上，还是把整群留在家里。 Anthropic 的 Claude Managed Agents 是托管 Agent API：定义 agent 后，由 Anthropic 运营沙箱、状态、工具和凭证。Orbi 是自托管的 GitHub 交付系统。两者都能把意图变成工作，所有权边界却不同。本页每条事实都标注来源与日期。
竞品，按其材料描述
Claude Managed Agents 是什么
Claude Managed Agents 是 Anthropic 的托管 Agent API：开发者定义 system prompt、工具、权限和 MCP 连接，Anthropic 负责沙箱、状态管理、工具编排、Vault 凭证存储与错误恢复。架构分三层：无状态且可替换的 Brain（推理）、一次性 Hands 沙箱（执行）、以及作为唯一持久层的 append-only Session 事件日志。服务于 2026-04-08 发布。Managed Agents 由 API 触发，不自带调度器或消息集成。
Sources: Anthropic (Managed Agents announcement and product materials) — verified 2026-09-07.
计价器就是产品的一部分
定价与运行边界
定价模型把标准 Claude token 价格与 Session 时长结合： Sonnet 4.6 的价格是 input $3/M、output $15/M，另加 $0.08/session-hour（按毫秒计，空闲不计）；web search 为 $10/千次。这是清晰的计价单位，但模型价格与服务容量都由 Anthropic 决定。
Sources: Anthropic pricing (token and web-search rates); Managed Agents documentation (session-hour billing) — verified 2026-09-07.
Managed Agents puts the cattle in Anthropic's cloud and rents them by the hour. Orbi keeps the delivery line on your machine, uses GitHub as its pasture, and lets you choose the model.
决定选择的差异
Orbi 与 Managed Agents 的差异
| Dimension | Orbi | Claude Managed Agents |
|---|---|---|
| Runs where | Your machine; code, keys, and state stay on your infrastructure | Anthropic cloud sandboxes, with credentials stored in its Vault |
| Task entry | GitHub Issue + ai-ready label; native scheduling through the task pool | API trigger; no built-in scheduler or messaging integration |
| Models | BYOK: any OpenAI-compatible endpoint, including free tiers | Claude only; Brain is Anthropic's replaceable reasoning layer |
| State | GitHub Issues, labels, branches, PRs, and local run evidence | Append-only Anthropic Session event log |
| Cost | Your hardware and model; no $/session-hour or platform fee | Claude token prices + $0.08/session-hour; web search $10/1,000 |
| Auditability | Fair-code source and GitHub-native evidence are inspectable | Managed service; implementation and infrastructure are Anthropic's |
Orbi column: Orbi documentation and repository. Managed Agents column: Anthropic product materials and pricing — verified 2026-09-07.
把 vendor 依赖说清楚
所有权边界意味着什么
托管服务可以是合适的运营选择，但它把价格、容量、模型可用性、数据处理和账号连续性都放进 vendor 关系里。 Anthropic 可以调整 token 或 session 价格、分配容量、制定访问政策。Vault 将凭证隔离在 Anthropic 基础设施内，但代码和任务上下文仍会经过该基础设施。Orbi 做相反的取舍：机器和集成由你运营，避免 Anthropic 特有的定价、模型与访问依赖。
Sources: Anthropic engineering materials — verified 2026-09-07. These are ownership trade-offs, not claims about service quality.
诚实的判断
该选哪一个？
事实来源
来源与核实日期
本页是一个有日期的快照。 做架构或采购决定前请再次核对 vendor 页面；下列来源均于 2026-09-07 核实。
- Anthropic official materials — Managed Agents launch, Brain/Hands/Session architecture, API scope, sandbox and Vault capabilitiesverified 2026-09-07anthropic.com
- Anthropic pricing — Claude token prices and web-search pricingverified 2026-09-07anthropic.com/pricing
- Orbi documentation and repository — the Orbi columnverified 2026-09-07docs.orbi.build · github.com/orbi-build/orbi
开源核心
拥有交付边界
Anthropic can be the right home for a product-embedded Claude agent. Orbi is the right home when the machine, model, and evidence need to remain yours.